PAULA'S SOUTHAMPTON BLOG: Paula Hathaway, REALTOR, LBA, ...The Most Informed Agent In The Hamptons! (Douglas Elliman Real Estate)

WHAT IS IT WITH TENANTS AND LANDLORDS?...No Amount Of Legal Council Is Too Much, IMHO!

WHAT IS IT WITH TENANTS AND LANDLORDS?...No Amount Of Legal Council Is Too Much, IMHO!

A HOUSE TIED UP IN RENTAL RED TAPEI don't know what is going on in your markets but here in the Hamptons, you can get burned really easy right now, especially if you are an agent and/or a landlord.

We have become a very large rental market here and because of that, the litigious nature of a few has become the dreaded fear of many. 

I spoke to my manager to day and he told me that we are changing our lease entirely--we are no longer going to give the courtesy of writing a lease for landlords because the changes that many agents and landlords decide they want in the standard lease are being done indiscriminately, leaving comments and markings all over the document. My advice to a homeowner who wants to rent their home out includes the following three things, without fail:

  1. Seek advice from a  lawyer--protect your investment of time and money from your tenant and a potential difficult tenancy.
  2. Make sure he generates a lease that is specific to your home and your requirements for a tenant.
  3. Also seek council on any local requirement for permits to rent out your home.

If you are a homeowner and you decide to rent your home, do not fail to get"GET OUT" legal guidance for your lease....You do not want to be in the situation many people have found themselves in here in the Hamptons. There are many little known facts that need to be adhered to or you could be in a lot of trouble:

  • A tenant took possession of a house with a lease that was not up to date in terms of the new Southampton Town Rental requirements. There was no permit for the rental and the tenant knew that the new requirement was in place for the landlord to have Town approval in order to rent the property out...Any code violations such as a gate that is not self closing near a pool, an alarm out of order on a child-protection door to the back yard, a bedroom in a basement without egress windows, etc. all needed to be brought up to date by the landlord in order to pass an inspection. In this one case the tenant knew of the law and knew that there was no permit; they took occupancy anyway and told the landlord that they would not pay any of the rent because he (the landlord) had not applied for a rental permit. The homeowner was held hostage to his tenant and under the guidance of a lawyer, they were forced to comply with the Town requirement and to repair any of the violations that were discovered during the application process. Any rent that was due up to the date of the approved permit was not required to be paid by the tenant...a whole month of free rent!


  • The security deposit monies, required to be paid by the tenant at the SECURITY SEPOSIT MONIES MUST BE KEPT SEPARATElease signing is not the property of the homeowner. It belongs to the tenant and must be held by the landlord in a separate account from the homeowners own money.--No co-mingling of funds. Many landlords do not know this and they end up spending the money as they do the rent money and in many cases they do not have the money to return to the tenant (minus applicable costs) at the end of the lease. This is an opportunity for a tenant to sue for damages and win back all of the deposit plus! I instruct all homeowners that they need to open a checking account for the tenants money with their bank so that they can keep that money separate from there own. At the time the tenant vacates the premises, the balance of the deposit, minus the bills paid by the landlord on behalf of the tenant, is paid back to the tenant. It is always wise to advise the landlord to create a simple checking account specifically for the tenants security deposit. (I always put it "in trust to" the tenant so in the event something happens to me, the tenant will be able to get his/her money without having to fight for it.) 


  • Most agents do not realize that once they secure a tenant/lease for a homeowner and once the commission is paid, the agent must not, for any reason go back on the property until that lease is over. This obscure part of the law in most states comes up only if and when there is a violation or a criminal act such as a theft of valuables from the home. It is best to stay away from the property at all costs, otherwise you could be included in any of the legal claims that can arise when the owner returns and finds missing valuables such as a painting or expensive vase or other "object de' art". All of the above are potential legal snags or encoumbrances that you, as an agent may get pulled into, because you have been paid a commission on the deal. Be aware of what the lease states and make sure it is generated by legal council; either your company's legal department or the landlords lawyer.

These practical recommendations will save you a lot of trouble if you are renting out your property for the first time or if you are an agent who handles rental properties.These items will also help you decide if you are really up for the term of the lease with all the encumbrances DON'T BE SORRY!and potential problems that can arise in the process. Landlord/tenant issues can ruin the enjoyment of your home and can become more problematic than you ever expected.

You want to feel safe, NOT sorry when it comes to turning your home over to a stranger!!!



                                     **ALL INFORMATION AND CONTENT IN THIS BLOG IS ORIGINAL TO PAULA I. HATHAWAY.  The views expressed herein are my personal views and do not reflect the views of Douglas Elliman Real Estate


Paula I. Hathaway, Senior Broker Associate, Douglas Elliman Real Estate

Southamtpon Village Real Estate Specialist since 1995;  Also Specializes in North Sea, Noyac, Water Mill and Bridgehampton, New York

Diamond , Gold and Chairman's Circle Awards; Top Producer since 2005


Click here to see my Hampton's website to see all my listings; please email me or call me for all your real estate needs in Southampton, Bridgehampton and Watermill:



Comment balloon 5 commentsPaula Hathaway, REALTOR, LBA • November 08 2013 01:49PM
WHAT IS IT WITH TENANTS AND LANDLORDS?… No Amount Of Legal Council Is Too Much, IMHO! I don't know what is going on in your markets but here in the Hamptons, you can get burned really easy right now, especially if you are an agent and/or a… more
DO YOU EVER TAKE A "FOR SALE BY COMMITTEE" LISTING?… IF SO READ ON… FOR SALE BY COMMITTEE… Your Good guidance is crucial in a Trust or Estate real estate sale. After recently handling several listings of this sort, I… more
CONDO SALES/DEMOGRAPHIC DATA… AN UPDATE: I wrote this post about two weeks ago and since then condo sales, Townhouses in particular have exploded! The brand new complex called Bishops Pond has sold all but 5 of the 50 units built… I have a… more
THE LOST ART OF PUMPIN CARVING… * Last year I found out there was a major offering of pumpkins on the back roads here in the Hamptons--there were farm stands and little pumpkin patches that the local farmers were selling pumpkins… more
CONDOS: SUDDENLY, LAST SUMMER… I just watched as 22 units of a total of 50 Condos at Bishops Pond went to contract here in Southampton Village this past summer. This follows a sudden surge in sales at the Polo Club Condos where 6… more
A NEW BLOG SITE IS LIKE A NEW PAIR OF SHOES! … A Bit Painful To Start; But give it some time and it WILL pay off! DO YOU REALLY WANT TO START A BLOG??? I wanted to write this post for those who think they want to start blogging but can’t… more
This is another part of a series of 3 posts on blogging and how important it is to the real estate community, nationwide. Without this form of marketing, I would be just another bump on the face of the Hamptons real estate market. Real estate agents… more
TELL ME A STORY… A Story About Real Estate and Local Information…
TELL ME A STORY… A Story About Real Estate and Local Information… Note: This is part of a series of posts about the importance of blogging to real estate agents and brokers--starting it, keeping it going and doing it with… more
TIPS TO SELL YOUR SOUTHAMPTON VILLAGE HOME: A BRIEF MARKET SUMMARY : In this customarily active real estate market here in Southampton Village, New York, we have seen a market shift from inactive in late 2008 into 2010, to very active… more
THE END OF PRIVACY… The "Hedge" Law Intrusion And Health…
T HE END OF PRIVACY… The "Hedge" Law Intrusion And Health Care House Calls! There have been 2 events in the past week that have given me a sense that this country has turned a corner; I am a law abiding citizen and I have… more